Athens Grow Green Coalition
  Candidate Scorecard 2004 Home - About Us - Calendar - Commissioners - Get Involved    


ACC Commission

Overall Scorecard
Incumbent Voting Record
Questionnaire + Answers:

District 2:
Sims
Smith

District 4:
Kinman
Tillery

District 6:
Jordan
Hadden
Beal

District 8:
McCarter
Nelson

Super District 10:
Kilpatrick
Dodson
Robinson

State Senate Dist. 46
Overall Scorecard
Incumbent Voting Record
(courtesy Georgia Conservation Voters)
Questionnaire + Answers

State House Dist. 115
Overall Scorecard
Questionnaire + Answers


Incumbent Voting Record

Date Issue AGGC position Dist. 2
Sims
Dist. 6
Jordan
Dist. 8
McCarter
Dist. 10
Kilpatrick
Oct 2000 75' Riparian Buffer - Motion to apply 75-foot buffers to perennial lakes and streams. Some Commissioners wanted 25 foot buffers - the least allowed by state law. Y N N/A N/A Y
Nov 2000 Oak Grove (Denny Hill) Rezoning  - Motion to approve rezoning 61 acres in the midst of the greenbelt on Jefferson Road from AR (Agricultural Residential) to single-family residential for the "Oak Grove" subdivision. The ACC Planning Commission recommended denial by an 8-1 vote.  N Y N/A N/A Y
Nov 2000 AR Zoning Option A - Allowed an average density of one unit per acre development throughout the county's AR zone as part of the ACC zoning ordinance, in spite of the Comprehensive Land Use Plan's call for 1 unit per 5 - 10 acres in AR zones. N Y N/A N/A Y
Dec 2000 Zoning Ordinance Veto Override
Motion to override Mayor Eldridge's veto of the zoning ordinance and Option A.
N Y N/A N/A Y
Feb 2001 Mixed-Use Fire Station in Five Points - Motion to reject the concept of a mixed-use fire station in Five Points (which had been proposed by UGA School of Environmental Design Dean Jack Crowley as a public-private partnership with potential to save millions of dollars in construction costs.) N Y N N Y
May 2001 Enron Partnership - Motion to enter into partnership with Enron Corp. to explore the feasibility of locating a natural gas-fired power plant in Athens along the North Oconee River. N Y N Y Y
Oct 2001 Olympic Dr. Rezoning from Employment-Industrial to Industrial - Motion to rezone this area from EI, which allows only light industry, to I, which allows heavy industry N N/A N Y Y

Oct

2001

Barnett Shoals Road Widening - Motion to approve the concept of a 5-lane road (4 travel lanes with a center turn lane) with no parking lot access road, sidewalks, bike lanes, or center median - even though the deletion of these from the plan would result in the loss of about $3 million in funding from GA DOT because they felt that such a design would result in an unsafe roadway. N N/A N Y Y
Oct 2001 Multi-family Building Permit Moratorium - Motion to implement a temporary moratorium on issuing building permits in RM zones, and authorizing a study of affordable housing in ACC (with the added opportunity to slow down the eviction process at the Garden Springs Mobile Home Park.) Y N/A N N N
Mar 2002 Bloomfield Rezoning - Motions to rezone 3 properties in this single-family historic neighborhood from single-family to multi-family, despite numerous neighborhood complaints about code violations by nearby multi-family unit renters. N N N Y Y
May 2002 Robert Hardeman Road "Conservation Subdivision" Rezoning - Motion to approve the rezoning of 125 acres in the AR zone and Airport Overlay district for a subdivision, despite lack of adequate infrastructure (roads, fire protection, sewer treatment plant at capacity.) N Y N N Y
Jan 2003 Conservation Subdivision Moratorium - Motion to approve temporary moratorium and direct Planning Dept. to re-write conservation subdivision rules Y N Y Y N
Feb 2003 Barnett Shoals Road Widening Bid - Motion to accept bid for project;last opportunity to stop it N Y N Y Y
Feb 2003 Spring Valley Rd. "conservation subdivision" rezoning - Motion to rezone 289 greenbelt acres for 289 houses N Y N N N
Mar 2003 Restore Prince Ave. to Bicycle Master Plan - Motion to return Prince Ave. to BMP (it had been removed at former Commissioner Hugh Logan's behest) Y Y Y Y Y
Apr 2003 Downtown Historic District - Motion to begin the process of historic designation for downtown Athens Y Y Y Y Y
Apr 2003 Citizen Stormwater Committee - Motion to direct Manager to appoint citizen committee to make recommendations about stormwater and water quality issues Y Y N Y Y
Apr 2003 Citizen Water Conservation Committee - Motion to appoint citizen committee to make recommendations about water conservation Y Y Y Y Y
Apr 2003 Multi-family building moratorium - Motion to place temporary moratorium on RM building permits and direct Planning staff to revamp RM design standards Y N Y Y Y
May 2003 Greenway Network Plan - Motion to adopt GNP Y Y Y Y Y

June 2003

FY 2004 MACORTS TIP - Motion to direct Mayor to vote in favor of FY2004 Transportation Improvement Program N Y N Y Y
Aug 2003 Prince Avenue crosswalks - Motion to install 2 mid-block crosswalks in busy pedestrian areas Y Y Y Y Y
Oct 2003 Bike lane standards - Motion to adopt standard width and striping for bike lanes Y Y Y Y Y
Oct 2003 Lumpkin Street 3 laning - Motion to reconfigure So. Lumpkin St. to 3 car lanes plus 2 bicycle lanes Y Y Y N N
Oct 2003 Rezone AR to 1:10 - Motion to amend conservation subdivision regulations and rezone AR from 1 unit per acre to 1 unit per 10 acres Y Y Y Y Y
Dec 2003 75 foot buffers - Motion to temporarily extend 75-ft protection to all streams while Citizen Stormwater Committee redraws buffer regulations Y N Y Y Y
Dec 2003 Rail-Trail funding - Motion to seek grant from DNR for rail-trail funding Y N Y N Y
Dec 2003 People of Hope rezoning - Motion to rezone 17 acres for PoH resident-controlled mobile home community to replace Garden Springs Y Y Y Y Y
May 2004 Bicycle Master Plan - Motion to accept Year 3 implementation schedule Y Y Y Y Y
May 2004 Perimeter Park-and-Ride - Motion to accept federal funds for park-and-ride lot to be located at College Station Road and the loop N N N Y Y
May 2004 Park-and-Ride TBD - Motion to accept federal funds for park-and-ride lot with location to be determined Y Y Y Y Y
June 2004 Rail-Trail funding - Motion to accept federal funding for Rail-Trail section closest to downtown Y Y Y N Y
July 2004 Drought management plan - motion to adopt proactive drought plan Y Y Y Y Y
July 2004 MACORTS 2030 LRTP - Motion to direct Mayor to vote in favor of 2030 Long Range Transportation Plan N Y N Y Y
July 2004 FY 2005 MACORTS TIP - Motion to direct Mayor to vote in favor of FY2005 Transportation Improvement Program N Y N Y Y
Aug 2004 $1.50 Link fare - Motion to set fare for The Link public transit service at $1.50 instead of $2.00 Y Y Y N Y
Aug 2004 SPLOST 2005 - Motion to approve project list including greenspace acquisition funds Y Y Y Y Y
Aug 2004 Parking lot standards - Motion to approve new parking lot site design standards with stronger tree requirements Y Y Y Y Y
Total votes in agreement
19 32 20 21
Total possible votes in agreeent
35 34 34 38
Percentage of agreement (numerical score)
54% 94% 59% 55%