Athens Grow Green Coalition
  Candidate Scorecard 2004 Home - About Us - Calendar - Commissioners - Get Involved    


ACC Commission

Overall Scorecard
Incumbent Voting Record
Questionnaire + Answers:

District 2:
Sims
Smith

District 4:
Kinman
Tillery

District 6:
Jordan
Hadden
Beal

District 8:
McCarter
Nelson

Super District 10:
Kilpatrick
Dodson
Robinson

State Senate Dist. 46
Overall Scorecard
Incumbent Voting Record
(courtesy Georgia Conservation Voters)
Questionnaire + Answers

State House Dist. 115
Overall Scorecard
Questionnaire + Answers


Super District 10 Questionnaire Responses

Kilpatrick (D,I)
Dodson (D)
Robinson (D)
 

1 Land Use, Planning and Zoning.

In 2000 the Commission passed a zoning ordinance that allowed suburban development at one unit per acre in the AR zone. In 2003 the Zoning and Development Standards were revised to change the AR zoning to 1 unit per 10 acres, and to remove some loopholes from the Conservation Subdivision regulations.
 

AGGC Kilpatrick (D, I) Dodson (D) Robinson (D)
1.a Do you believe that with these revisions the current zoning ordinance is adequate to protect Athens-Clarke County from sprawl?
N Y N N
1.b If not, what else can and should local government do to curb sprawl?
  The 2000 development code required a conservation subdivision for the development at one unit per acre. I voted against that part of the code. I didn't like the idea of a conservation subdivision as a special use because I believe a special use puts everyone in the situation of not knowing what will be required. It turns out I predicted what the problem would be. I'm comfortable with the current conservation use ordinance and the ratio of 1/10 outright. These are a step in the right direction, but sprawl is something the county must constantly be vigilant about. Like weeds, sprawl will continue to try to creep in wherever it can. Therefore, while I believe the zoning changes are effective stop gap measures, our community needs innnovative long term solutions to our growth problems. I believe that many of these solutions involve a potentially powerful tool: conservation easements. The density allowances in the AR zoning ordinance provide an adequate transitional background for these approaches. One example of such an innovation lies in transferable development rights ("TDRs"). I believe TDRs allow a win-win situation of compensating property owners while retaining necessary greenspace and protecting essential natural resources for generations to come. In all cases, the M&C MUST adhere to the principals that guided the formulation of our master plan.

Athens has a number of unique characteristics that limit our control over growth here. We are very small in size, our job market is determined by outside entities and our roads are built by a state transportation authority which is weighted in favor of the surrounding counties. The result is that growth will come to Athens, and if we are not careful with our plannign, it will result in sprawl. If the UGA regents say that UGA enrollment will swell by 5000, then we can expect an additional 5,000 to 10,000 additional people attracted by the resulting support jobs. If the only thing we accomplish is locking up the green-space in Athens, then the growth will simply skip over the greenspace, down DOTs extravagant feeder roads into other counties. In essence, if we only protect our greenspace, then all we will have done is exacerbate the problems of sprawl by forcing it further out.

In order for smart growth to happen we must do a number of things. The first of these is to create a system for pushing growth inwards and creating density. This will require a system of Transferable Development Rights. We must identify places in Athens, such as the perimeter and Milledge, ro some of the old industrial sites along the CSX line, where we can add new, dense housing. Then we must establish at TDR system to allow dense development there in exchange for protecting greenspace. A nice bonus to this is that it allows people to pay the landowners in the green zones so they don't feel like they have lost the development value of their land. Ultimately, this program may reuqire a regional approach to TDRs because of our small size.

Further, to make this work, we must have sensible zoning codes. Our codes are now overly-simplistic definitions of four types - single family, multi-family, commercial and industrial. For dense, livable growth to occur, we must redefine these so we get more row-housing, mixed-use and upwards development. We must create zoning that will mix the present types of development and open up the sharp-division between single family and multi-family we now have for these growth zones. Additionally, we need building codes which reinforce realistic small-lot development and don't hamper growth. In other words, we need zoning ordinances that reinforce the vision of our land-use plan rather than ordinances that hinder it. Our zoning, at present, contains no workable vision of implementing the land use plan and we must make our zoning maps and land-use maps overlap. We must have Zoning that reflects and supports our land use plan so we can begin to implement it.

Further, we must reconsider how we define downtown/urban codes so that we can also grow upwards in some areas. At present, there is a 100ft limit downtown. If you take into account topography, this limit is not useful. It is too high near the top of the hill downtown, and far too low in the hole at the bottom of Broad Street. We must reconsider the use and placement of height in our town and not be afraid to use it in dense areas.

Further, we absolutely must start a discussion about regional planning. If our land-use map does not line up with the surrounding counties maps, then we cannot stop sprawl from h appening. A good example is the end of Barnett Shoals Road at Oconee County. Barnett Shoals in Athens ends near a country club and this area is slatted for medium density suburbs in both Oconee and Ogelthorpe counties. If this area grows as they plan, there will be thousands of people living there, all of whom work in Athens. Of course, they will not drive out to Watkinsville to come to work in Athens. Instead, t hey will drive up Barnett Shoals, thus requiring us to widen a road we shish to remain low density. We must stop this by convincing our neighbors to make their maps match with ours. I know a number of people are very pessimistic about this, but I believe that there are a number of ways we can approach this problem which will result in positive change. We can and must make the attempt, or we are doomed to failure.

Finally, we must, somehow, take control of our own transportation planning. I do not know how we can get DOT to cooperate, but we must stop the creation of additional feeder roads such as the widening of the Jefferson Highway. Instead, we must get a plan going which reinforces more and denser development in our core. This means more walkable areas, more mass-transit, and a people centered street design in all areas except our primary feeder roads.

One other area for concern is also our sewer master plan. Development tends to follow sewer lines. We need to create a good sewer plan which will get our residential areas with small lots (e.g. Green Acres (yes, it does have anumber of houses on septic)) off of septic in a manner which does not, in any way, create access to these lines from our greenspace. We must make sure that these plans are created and that they do not enter our greenspace. We need to do this now so future commissions can not undo this planning.

1.c The new conservation subdivision regulations contain requirements for identification and protection of significant natural areas. Do you support extending these requirements to other types of development?
Y Y Y Y
1.d Do you support adding an Urban Planner position to the Planning Department?
Y Y Y Y
1.e Do you support implementing a Neighborhood Planning Unit program?
Y Y Y Y- I think the CAPPA group is doing a great job of demonstrating to us what NPU planning might look like. If we had a group like this, with finished vignettes, and they were the first reviewing body for development plans, we could really have development neighborhood focused.
1.f What other suggestions, if any, do you have for improving the process of neighborhood input?
  I wish all neighborhoods would involve their commissioners in their meetings. I really do want to hear what people think about all kinds of issues. I support the neighborhood input requirements of the revised conservation subdivision ordinance, but I would like to see a more far-reaching and more formalized process for community input. I am heartened by the efforts of CAPPA (Community Approach to Planning Prince Avenue), and I hope that process will help us understand how best to evolve our development and zoning processes. This understanding will assist our community in developing NPUs and instituting a structure for community pre-planning input that can be applied throughout the county (and serve as a model for other communities as well). Our government MUST be proactive in reaching out to neighborhoods and assisting us with digesting often complex and highly technical information, rather than waiting for constituents to come to them (often after it is too late for meaningful community involvement in the process.)

We should make neighborhood organizations such as the neighborhood federation or the neighborhood roundtable actual citizens advisory groups overseeing some departments such as the ordinance enforcement department. We need to establish NPUs and within these define the overall vision for how we want the different parts of our town to develop. The NPUs can then become the first line of planning approval so all new development will fit within the vision neighborhoods have set fgor themselves and their future growth. CAPPA is a good working example of how this can be accomplished. We need to expand the possibilitites of how land is zoned. Our land use map has a highly variegated vision for how Athens will develop. But we have a paucity of zoning types. These broad-brush types do not allow us to fully define how we want development to proceed so that we will have a town that will end up looking like the vision in our master plan. We must have more highly articulated zoning that is more closely tied to our land-use master plan.

We need to dedicate SPLOST funds specifically for neighborhood improvement. Neighborhood boards or associations could decide how to allocate these funds to various projects such as neighborhood parks, sidewalks, etc. Let neighborhoods pick the projects and the contractors. A neighborhood organization should have first review of all planning decisions for that neighborhood. This would be part of any good NPU system.


2 Natural Resources.
The Commission recently voted to temporarily extend 75-foot riparian buffer protection to all perennial streams in ACC. Acting under state and federal requirements, the Commission also adopted new erosion and sedimentation and stormwater management ordinances that are meant to protect water quality.
 
AGGC Kilpatrick (D, I) Dodson (D) Robinson (D)
2.a Are you in favor of permanently extending 75-foot riparian buffer protection to all perennial streams in ACC?
Y Y Y Y - In my understanding, we use and old USGS map to identify the perennial stream in the county, and this leaves off many streams that are perennial. We not only need to expand the buffer, wen eed a better survey of where the streams are.
2.b Do you support the creation of a stormwater utility to fund stormwater management?
Y Y Y Y
2.c Do you think ACC needs to do more to enhance alternative transportation options?
Y Y Y Y
2.d Do you support the rail-to-trail project, including the bridges which will provide a level connection from the Greenway to the Multi-Modal center?
Y Y Y Y
2.e ACC’s tree canopy has declined significantly during the last 20 years, and the rate of decline is accelerating. Do you support adopting a tree protection ordinance to prevent clear-cutting for development?
Y Y Y Y - I'm helping write one.
2.f Do you support the SPLOST 2005 proposals for funding the protection of greenspace?
Y Y Y Y
2.g What else can ACC do to protect greenspace?
  Developing a TDR program might increase greenspace through conservation areas. I worked to get the TDR enabling legislation through the General Assembly by working through the Assoc. of County Commissioners of GA and Sen. Doug Haines. Since then I have nominated people for the TDR development committee three times. We need to flesh out that idea to find out if it's feasible for Athens-Clarke County. For one, the M&C must be mindful of infrastructure placement, ensuring that sewage and water lines service our neighborhoods as necessary but do not encourage unwanted development corridors through our greenspace. Most importantly, Athens-Clarke must work towards actively involving the community in our development process. Developers currently have a heavy handed influence on the process because they have a substantial financial interest which allows them to present a singular unified lobbying power. Citizens, on the other hand, represent diverse interests and backgrounds. However, I believe that we are capable of crafting a process which empowers neighborhoods and encompasses the best interests of our community. I am convinced that greenspace protection will flow naturally from such a process.

We need topographically sensitive zoning regulations. We need an ordinance forbidding devleopment on highly sloped land. Additionally, we might want to restrict building on areas with sensitive hydrology. Protecting highly sloped land is only found in the newly revised conservation subdivision ordiannce. It needs to be applied to all zoning types. Finally, we should limit development in areas with exposed granite. The tree ordinance in the works will likely remove the need for a development envelope in RS areas, but it is still soemthing we should investigate since minimally invasive devleopment is more than just preserving the tree canopy. We need to identify all of the perennial streams in Athens. Only some of our perennial streams are mapped by the USGS maps used by planning and it is these maps that are often used to determine where and when to investigate compliance with our stream buffers. Finally, we need a system of city parks and neighborhood parks separate from the overall greenway plan.

Greenspace also means local, small scale spaces. These parks may be completely domesticated, but they increase the health and welfare of neighborhood residents. Another resource issue, not related to greenspace, is water conservation. Our population is challenging our water resources and we need to develop ways to encourage water conservation and the use of less water intensive landscaping.


3 Affordable Housing.
Affordable housing has been a topic of debate for several years. Mobile home parks and low-priced apartment buildings continue to be converted to other uses, and the value of land close to downtown (and accessible to services) is rising dramatically, leading to the frequent displacement of low-income families and individuals. Much of the housing that is affordable to low-income residents is in substandard condition, and /or located far from access to services.
 
AGGC Kilpatrick (D, I) Dodson (D) Robinson (D)
3.a Is preserving low-income residents' access to safe, decent, accessible affordable housing a priority of yours?
Y Y Y Y
3.b Should it be a priority of local government?
Y Y Y Y
3.c What will you do to increase safe, decent, accessible affordable housing options in ACC?
  Safe, decent, accessible affordable housing is a need which reuqires the collaboration of several groups in the community. I have consistently supported efforts of the Athens Land Trust, the Athens Housing Authority, the East Athens Development Center, and the Hancock Corridor. Unfortunately, the plan for the Fourth Street area failed to receive the desired funding. I will continue to support groups who are working toward this necessary housing. For our Senior Citizens, I would support an ordinance which freezes property taxes once homeowners reach age 65. We do not what those who have invested in this county for 30, 40 or 50 years to be taxed out of the homes they purchased years ago. For the large percentage of our citizens living in poverty, I will advocate against "slum lords"who take advantage of those with few resources. I also will work to bring in better paying jobs (see #4b), and help insure people have adequate transportation to keep their jobs. More generally, rather than imposing my own assumptions about what will solve problems, I will continue to reach out to the community members themselves to find out exactly what obstacles are preventing people from having adequate access to affordable housing. The housing problem in this town begins with the housing market. The university and the affluent students it attracts, as well as the lack of sufficient on-campus housing, create a huge demand for rental property that eliminates much of the affordable housing stock close to town where we need it. We need quality housing that is affordable near town because this is where it is most needed. This is where most of the people who need it work. Unfortunately, the prices for these properties are being driven up by the rental and young professional markets.

The solutions generally pushed by the developers are to create cheap housing. This means small, low-quality housing further and further out of town. The distance is a huge impediment for our lower-wage workers because cars are expensive and we do not have adequate mass-transit. Additionally, the prospect of simply supporting affordable housing by simply moving it out to cheaper areas is not in the best-interests of Athens. This non-solution would require building a very expensive, subsidized transportation infrastructure (e.g. a large route bus system) which is much more expensive than the savings we get from allowing it to be further out of town.

Finally, we need to recognize that affordable housing is NOT cheap housing. We need quality housing that is subsidized, and is close to town and the other places where people work. In other words, we need a comprehensive system for subsidizing housing. We have some of the pieces in place, such as the Athens Housing Authorities apartment system. But we must also make sure that affordable neighborhoods remain near downtown. To do this, we need to expand the mortgage subsidized hosuing programs in Athens, both those that are government run and those run bynon-profits such as habitat and the Athens land Trust.

One of the first things I think we need to do is define areas we want to remain affordable housing. One problem we have is that the rental developers pay finders fees to real-estate agents, so they end up getting the properties they want. After a while, this breaks up communities so that areas that were self-supporting, become fragmented and wither. New Town is a good example. So we must identify the areas we want to remain affordable.

Then, we must create a bond pool to buy up these properties as they come on tehmarket. We cannot solely rely on federal funding and the generosity of non-profits for our affordable hsouigns needs. At present, the city is relying solely on HOME and CDBG funds for its affordable housing projects. So our second step needs to be to create the pool of money we can use to stabilize these affordable housing neighborhoods. Additionally, we should not use CDBG funds to support items that are recurring and mandated expenses. An example would be the Elderly Transportation funds which we use CDBG money to support out of the Council on Aging. This is a federally mandated service and we should pay for it out of general revenue costs and not out of CDBG. Another example would be water-line extensions we fund for a profit making enterprise: Sewer and Utilities.

Then, the city should acquire all of the housing in areas threatened with upscaling whenever a house is sold. We can use the bond pool to fix them up and sell them at affordable rates. The agreements on the sales will include the normal 10 years to sell clause, but they should also include a right of first refusal for the city or managing agency to purchase these properties at market rates. In this way, the city and our secondary agencies will have sufficient funding through the bond pool and a legal means to re-acquire properties and keep affordable neighborhoods near town intact.

In addition, we need to explore some other avenues of creating more transitional housing. Presently, most of our efforts are focused on either apartment projects or home ownership. We must also explore the use of self-controlled affordable housing systems such as cooperatives. And, we must also look at how we zone and develop very low-cost starter homes such as the People of Hope are doing and, when we find workable projects such as taht, we must make sure they are fully funded.

3.d Some communities in Georgia, such as Americus and Valdosta, have affordable housing goals that include having no substandard housing within their communities. Do you think Athens should adopt such a goal?
Y Y Y Y - many local developers confuse dense-low-quality (i.e. cheap) housing with affordable housing. Affordable housing is quality housing subsidized at affordable rates. Affordable housing is also convenient housing. A home is not affordable if the cost of transportation to a person workplace is outside of their means. Transportatio is part of the affordable housing equation.


4 Business and the Environment.
There has recently been much debate over whether government decisions that provide environmental protection (riparian buffers, revisions to the conservation subdivision regulations, etc.) are “unfriendly” to business.
 

AGGC Kilpatrick (D, I) Dodson (D) Robinson (D)
4.a Do you believe that Athens-Clarke County's environmental regulations are at odds with business development?
N N N N
4.b What kinds of businesses should Athens try to attract?
  A study of the Athens business mix showed that the medical area paid the best wages and had the most potential. I support that study as well as the work toward biotechnology. We also need to look for businesses that will employ those who lost their manufacturing jobs. Although Athens boasts a low unemployment rate, many of the jobs in our community are based ont eh service industry. Because many of these kinds of jobs are very poorly paid and lack essential health benefits, they only exacerbate the poverty problem. With the wonderful quality oflife we have to offer, Athens should reach out to businesses that bring adequate salaries and decent benefits for its workers. Working in employment law, I see the profoundly negative effects of poor treatment, low wages, andno benefits on our working families. I would be pleased to see more high-tech jobs which take advantage of our university environment. However, we have deep need for jobs that will employ relatively unskilled labor and assist us in elevating the substantial portion of our workforce that lives in poverty. Finally, at no time should the M&C respond positively to threats by industry that they will relocate if we do not grant substantial exceptions to our development principals, such as the stream buffer. small start up high-tech; computer programming and other low-impact technology; media arts; light-weight middle-wage assembly/manufacturing; support-desk, help-desk, telecommunication; environmental sciences; bio-tech (expecially agricultural); entertainment; tourism.

back to top